In Smolik v Bejaoui [2024] EWHC 920 (Fam), Mr. Justice Francis of the High Court ordered the return of Elena Smolik, a 4-year-old child wrongfully retained in Slovakia by her father, Rastislav Smolik, after an agreed holiday. The mother, Wiem Bejaoui, successfully sought the return of her daughter to England, her habitual residence. The court expressed concern over the father's apparent premeditation in retaining the child and his refusal to facilitate any contact between Elena and her mother since November 2023. The court emphasized the father's breach of the agreement and the impact on the child and mother, granting the mother permission to publicize the judgment to aid in Elena's return.
Case Overview:
Case Name: Smolik v Bejaoui (Elena Smolik: Child Abduction)
Court: High Court of Justice, Family Division
Judgment Date: 20 March 2024
Judge: Mr. Justice Francis
Keywords: Child Abduction, Return Order, Habitual Residence, Parental Rights
Legal Issues:
Child Abduction and Retention:
The case involved the wrongful retention of Elena Smolik by her father in Slovakia after a holiday agreed upon by both parents. Despite a return date of 31 October 2023, the father failed to bring Elena back to England, citing a lost passport as the reason. The court, however, found this excuse unconvincing and likely indicative of a premeditated abduction.
Habitual Residence:
The court confirmed that Elena's habitual residence was in England and Wales at the time of her departure, making the father's retention of the child in Slovakia wrongful under both domestic and international law, including the Hague Convention.
Court’s Analysis:
Absence of the Father: The court noted the father's absence from the proceedings and his failure to provide any justification for his actions, further raising suspicion about the legitimacy of his claims.
Impact on the Child: The judgment highlighted the severe emotional and psychological impact on Elena, who has been deprived of contact with her mother for nearly five months.
Legal Precedent: The court considered the principles set out in Re S (Abduction: Hague Convention or BIIa) [2018] EWCA Civ 1226, where applications should generally be made in the country where the child is taken. However, the mother’s lack of access to legal aid in Slovakia justified her application in the English courts.
Judgment Summary:
The High Court issued a return order for Elena Smolik, emphasizing the father's breach of the agreement and the potential premeditation in his actions. The mother was granted permission to publicize the judgment to facilitate her daughter's return. The court expressed hope that public pressure might encourage the father to comply with the order and return Elena to England, where any custody disputes should be resolved.
Implications:
This case underscores the court's commitment to upholding international child abduction laws and protecting the rights of the child to maintain contact with both parents. The judgment also highlights the importance of considering the practical barriers faced by parents in cross-border legal disputes, such as access to legal aid.
References:
Re S (Abduction: Hague Convention or BIIa) [2018] EWCA Civ 1226
Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction
For full details, refer to the published judgment.
Comments